Paying It Forward Storefront

If you’d like to stop by the store, in person, please head here:

Paying It Forward is located at 819 W Chicago Ave, East Chicago, IN 46312.

If you’d like to mail something from our Wishlist, Amazon will automatically mail it to the correct address.

If you’d like to ship something directly to us, you can ship it here:

Paying It Forward’s mailing address is 4328 Olcott St, East Chicago IN, 46312.

Why does Paying It Forward have a different shipping address from its office address? 

Paying It Forward’s main office and storefront is located on a busy main street. Many deliveries arrive after regular business hours and are at risk of theft, so they cannot be left outside. We route our deliveries to Paying It Forward’s headquarters located at 4328 Olcott St, East Chicago IN, 46312.

What is Paying It Forward’s contact number?

You can reach us at 219-318-3122. 

Calls and texts are accepted Monday - Friday, 11:00 am - 7:00 pm. To reach Paying It Forward after hours, you can do so by emailing: info@payingitforwardnwi.com

What are Paying It Forward office hours? 

Our current office hours are Monday - Friday, 11:00 am - 5:00 pm. We are closed on Saturday and Sunday.